Don’t try so hard..

A few days ago, I was sent a link to an interesting article based on Sian Beilock’s work on the art of the choke (or more accurately about what causes this to happen in pressure situations).

Here is the link:

http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/frontal-cortex/2012/06/the-new-neuroscience-of-choking.html?mobify=0

 

The story touches on a few aspects of my game that I have been thinking about lately, namely that the more I care about a shot or round the worse I seem to do.   Apparently, what happens is our brains emphasize loss over gain and when there is something larger than normal on the line, we sabotage ourselves when the thought of not losing overshadows the incentives to win.  Whether there is $100 on the line for a final hole or a spot in the US Open, we process that as a potential loss and not as the potential payout.  This freezes us and causes a type of paralysis in our learned skill sets, which in turn lessens our ability to perform.

From everything I have read and heard this is not uncommon, so it’s not a surprise that when I get down to the 17th hole of a round where I am just 4 over I have a blow-up hole.  We’ve all been there.  But, with this new information, I think it is possible to consciously control the situation.  Knowledge is strength and knowing what your brain is thinking is the first step to being able to overcome it.

For the past two days since reading this story, I have been trying to try less during rounds.  I have been keeping an even keel in my aggressiveness in a round and regardless of the hole or score I have not raised my concerns during the round.  It has paid off, even if in a barely perceptible way.  I shot an 81 yesterday out at Columbia Edgewater, which is my best score on that track to date and then today shot an 80 on the Great Blue course at Heron Lakes.  Both rounds felt much easier than any round in the past and the only difference was that I was trying to not try so hard.  I know it will be different when there is actually something big on the line, but if you can’t do it in practice then there is no way you can do it in competition, so starting here is the best option for the long term.

Today, I ran into a friend who was out on the range practicing for the Oregon Amateur qualifier coming up this weekend.  It’s a big tournament here (probably the most competitive in Oregon and you have to have under a 5 handicap just to get considered for the qualifier) and he was getting ready three days in advance by only practicing and not playing any golf.  This is a complete change to how he normally approaches tournament rounds and I think that he might be sabotaging himself by emphasizing the tournament too much.  If he enters Sunday with a week of built up anticipation he will be setting himself up for too much potential loss and risks the brain taking over in a negative way.  You have to want to win and visualize yourself winning, but you shouldn’t change your ways leading up to a competition.  Instead, trust what you have been working on for such a long time and go out to enjoy the tournament and do as well as you can.   The best results come from a relaxed and well focussed mind, a mind that is not over-pressured by the idea of loss.

Next time you have something on the line, try to not try so hard.  Just be yourself and trust in your preparation.

  • Michael

    Hi,

    i experienced exactly the same, don’t think, just do it. In golf this really works.

    Bye
    Michael

  • Michael

    In ‘pressure’ situations I always try to take the mental approach of either learning as much as I can, or just having fun, depending on the nature of the situation. This seems to work well to release the concern about the outcome.

  • Jim Walters

    I couldn’t agree more with this blog entry. My best “feeling” round (didnt putt well so score wasnt the best) was when I was just swinging away without a care in the world, not worrying at all of the failure aspect. My playing partners all commetned on how natural and relaxed the swing was, and I actually hit a lot of very nice shots. It is definitely the way to go.
    I hope you remember this Dan when you are on the tour! I am sure it easier said than done ;-)

  • williamevanl

    Whenever I think about human behavior I always wonder how something is evolutionarily adaptive. Nearly everything make sense when you think about it. You get scared when you’re outside in the woods late at night (more perceptive, able to respond to danger). If there’s danger you get adrenaline (fight/flight). You experience pain (preventing you from further hurting yourself) etc…

    Curious though how something like this would perpetuate itself in the species. How in the world can crumbling when faced with a high pressure situation be adaptive, why would that be built in and why wouldn’t it be selected against? It should be the exact opposite, ancestors that performed better under pressure should have had better survivability.

  • http://hoopvision.blogspot.com Jordan

    The concept in this blog seems to me like it’s the complete opposite of the 10,000 hour rule and the Dan Plan in general. The idea that success is simply related to hard work is very empowering. This means that whoever wants to achieve something the most is in theory going to be the one who gets it. In this sense, “caring” would seem to be essential to success.

    The first thing I thought of was this video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lsSC2vx7zFQ

    ^features the quote “When you want to succeed as bad as you want to breathe, then you’ll be successful”

  • Brandon Cotman

    Thanks for this post. Learning how not to choke in the middle of the fight is half the battle.

  • Tom

    This is good advice for some, but not unilaterally good advice.

    Some people are better under pressure.

  • http://thedanplan.com dan

    Hello Jim,

    Since I read about this and put it into play on the course, I have had the best four consecutive rounds to date, so it looks like it is paying off so far.

    Feel the ball….

    Dan

  • http://thedanplan.com dan

    William,

    Interesting thought you have there. I’m not really sure why stressful situations cause “choking” to the majority of people. Perhaps we should ask a psychologist this?

    Thanks,

    Dan

  • http://thedanplan.com dan

    Jordan,

    I think the main point (that I perhaps didn’t get across well in the blog) is that you need to focus on your mechanics and skill building during practice and then trust what you have and let yourself be in the moment during competition. Try not to paralyze yourself with over thinking during competition, save the thoughts for the range and trust your skills when on the course. During great clutch performances, people are not thinking about every detail of what they are doing, they just do it. Deliberate practice is used to build up to that point.

    Dan

  • http://thedanplan.com dan

    Tom,

    Definitely agree that some people are better under pressure. I think it is because they have trained and are confident in their acquired skill set and so can let it fly in a tournament situation.

  • Chris

    Dan you might have answered this question already, but do you take a break from the game? Now that this is your job, do you take vacation? Enjoy reading the blog and keeping track of your progress.

  • Ed

    I agree with your thought process. I think the key point is to learn to practice and compete with the same focus and mindset. If you can combine “care free” and intense focus on executing the shot, that is a great start. Then you have to learn to not be thinking about ramifications when making shots when competing. I think the ramifications either good or bad are the wrong thought…although positive is always better than negative if they happen to creep in on you. You need to focus on the shot in front of you, period. Good luck and great work so far on your journey.